FACT CHECK: Journo’s tweet on Mindanao tourism vis-à-vis kidnapping surge lacks context

(Editor’s note: This story was updated to include the advisories of some foreign governments to their citizens against travelling to some parts of Mindanao.)

Mindanao. A recent tweet by journalist Raissa Robles that opening up Mindanao to tourism will lead to a rise in kidnapping activities by the Abu Sayyaf Group (ASG) and other bandits lacks context.

On June 2, Robles quote-tweeted a post by Twitter user @Pulitika2010 involving an article link published by broadsheet Business Mirror entitled  ‘New tourism chief: In ‘unity’ there will be fun.’

A screenshot of Robles’ quote-tweet.

Robles was commenting on the plan of incoming Tourism Secretary Christina Garcia-Frasco to promote lesser-known tourism destinations in the country.

The writer’s post stirred a furor from various stakeholders in Mindanao who protested the negative portrayal of the island as a haven of kidnappers.

The Abu Sayyaf, which means “Bearer of the Sword” in Arabic, was founded by Afghan-trained militant Abdurajak Abubakar Janjalani to establish an independent Islamic state in Mindanao upon his return in 1991 to Basilan, one of the 27 provinces in the southern Philippines.

It later engaged in terroristic attacks and kidnapping activities, including the abduction of 21 people, mostly foreigners, from a dive resort in Sipadan, Malaysia and 20 foreign and local tourists from the Dos Palmas Beach Resort in Palawan, which belongs to Luzon island, in the early 2000s.

The Abu Sayyaf Group (ASG), which the United States classified as a foreign terrorist organization as early as 1997, has been known to operate in Basilan and Sulu, island-provinces belonging to what is now known as the Bangsamoro Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (BARMM).

BARMM, with a population of at least 4.4 million people, is one of the six regions in Mindanao, the country’s second largest island-grouping whose total population stood at 26.25 million as of May 2020. Mindanao has 27 provinces and 33 cities.

The six regions in Mindanao and their corresponding populations as of 1 May 2020.

The Western Mindanao Command of the Armed Forces of the Philippines estimated the number of ASG fighters, who are mostly operating in Basilan and Sulu, at 300 two years ago. https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1091712

In a March 2022 report, the International Crisis Group, a non-profit peace advocacy organization, said the ASG forces in Basilan and Sulu have been weakened although not yet defeated. https://www.crisisgroup.org/asia/south-east-asia/philippines/323-addressing-islamist-militancy-southern-philippines

Stressing the strides of the government against the ASG,Defense Secretary Delfin Lorenzana said that 1,544 Abu Sayyaf members were neutralized by the military in the last six years under the Duterte administration, which means they were either killed, arrested or surrendered to authorities. https://mb.com.ph/2022/05/30/six-years-of-hits-and-misses-the-security-justice-peace-situation-under-duterte-administration/

In the past several years, the Abu Sayyaf, despite being weakened, still managed to snatch victims, including the abduction in September 2015 of three foreigners and a Filipina in Samal Island, Davao del Norte. Two of the foreigners were beheaded while the two others were freed separately. In October 2019, the Abu Sayyaf also abducted a British national and his wife in Tukuran, Zamboanga del Sur. They were later rescued by government forces in Sulu.

In May 2017, the ASG joined forces with the Maute Group in staging the Marawi siege in a failed bid to establish the country’s only Islamic city as a province of the Islamic State in Southeast Asia. The five-month urban warfare left the core of Marawi in rubble. The national government has conducted construction works to rebuild the city.

The United States, United Kingdom and Australia have issued travel advisories to their citizens against travelling to some parts of Mindanao, including the Sulu archipelago due to the threats of terrorism and kidnapping. https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/traveladvisories/traveladvisories/philippines-travel-advisory.html https://www.gov.uk/foreign-travel-advice/philippines/safety-and-security#local-travel https://www.smartraveller.gov.au/destinations/asia/philippines

Despite the kidnapping incidents and the travel advisories of some countries, the Department of Tourism (DOT), particularly its officials in Mindanao, still remained zealous in promoting the island as a premier tourist destination in the country over the years.

Last month, outgoing Tourism Secretary Bernadette Romulo-Puyat led the launching of the “Colors of Mindanao,” a campaign to promote Mindanao’s destination, diverse culture, landscape and food offerings. https://www.facebook.com/colorsofmindanao/

“While each province is known for their unique attributes, this is the first time that the whole of Mindanao is united under one banner,” Romulo-Puyat stressed.

The campaign was spearheaded by Tourism Undersecretary for Mindanao Myra Paz Valderrosa-Abubakar and the regional directors of Zamboanga Peninsula, Northern Mindanao, CARAGA, the Davao region and Soccsksargen.

The recent sweeping claim of Robles, who writes for the South China Morning Post, that opening up tourism in Mindanao will give the Abu Sayyaf potential kidnap victims has been resented by Mindanao leaders and bashed by netizens.

Representative Mujiv Hataman of the lone district of Basilan, where the Abu Sayyaf originated, said the ASG is no “longer a threat” in the area, noting the province’s Program Against Violent Extremism has become effective in encouraging the bandits to return to mainstream society.

“Since 2016, there’s no kidnapping in Basilan,” said Hataman, who also served as governor of the defunct Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao.

Vice President-elect Sara Duterte, incumbent mayor of Davao City, said the views expressed by Robles on Mindanao in reaction to the plan of the incoming tourism secretary to develop the region as a tourist destination “are replete with journalistic recklessness and irresponsibility — something that calls for our collective condemnation as it grossly discriminated against all Mindanawons, especially those living in Moro communities.” 

“What Robles did was a demonization of Mindanao and an insult to its people, who also deserve to experience the gains of the Duterte administration over the past six years,” the presidential daughter said in a statement.

In a succeeding social media post, Robles defended her tweet.

“What I’m saying here is that parts of Mindanao are not ready for tourism due to security issues. So if the Department of Tourism launches a program welcoming tourists in all of Mindanao, I fear this will be a magnet for bandits and kidnappers to prey on unwitting tourists,” she wrote.

Presidential Adviser on Peace, Reconciliation and Unity Carlito Galvez, Jr. said the peace and order condition in Mindanao has significantly improved with the implementation of the provisions of the Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro (CAB). https://peace.gov.ph/2022/03/galvez-lauds-improved-security-stability-in-sulu-opapru-lays-groundwork-to-help-transform-former-combatants-camps-into-peaceful-resilient-communities/

The CAB was signed by the government and the Moro Islamic Liberation Front in 2014 after 17 years of negotiations. Its key component is the creation of the Bangsamoro region, which was realized in 2019 following a plebiscite that ratified the Republic Act 11054 or the Organic Law for the BARMM.

President Rodrigo Duterte earlier said he will be leaving the presidency with a relatively peaceful Mindanao.

As with all our other reports, MindaNews welcomes leads or suggestions from the public to potential fact-check stories. (Yas D. Ocampo and Bong S. Sarmiento / MindaNews)

(This fact-check piece was produced with the support of Internews’ Philippine Fact-Checker Incubator Project.)

-- ad here--

About MindaNews Fact Check

MindaNews Fact Check seeks to fight misinformation and disinformation circulating on the internet, news platforms and communities that we serve. 

What is MindaNews Fact Check?

MindaNews Fact Check tracks and debunks fake news, false claims and misleading statements of government officials, civil society leaders and netizens being spread on the internet, especially on social media sites. MindaNews values truth and accuracy in performing our journalistic work.

Why we fact-check?

Politicians, government officials and other public and private figures at times tend to bend facts to suit or advance their vested interests, or their principals, in effect misleading the public. The distorted facts spread easily with the popularity of the internet and the wide influence of social media.

As independent journalists, our primordial duty is to tell the truth and present facts to help the public discern issues and concerns impacting their lives.

How do we rate claims?

FAKE -  if the claim is completely invented.

FALSE - if the claim contradicts, undermines or disputes truthful facts, actual events and official records (i.e. laws and scientific studies)

MISLEADING – if the claim is based on truth but maliciously twisted that gives a different impression to serve a group or individual’s vested interests.

ALTERED – pertains to images or videos that were manipulated to mislead the public.

MISSING CONTEXT – if the claim needs more clarification or contextualization to make it clearer.

Where do you post your results?

We post our fact-checked stories in www.mindanews.com, on Facebook and Twitter with links to the original piece. We have a dedicated fact check page, where all fact-checked stories can be found. 

How did MindaNews Fact Check start?

Since its establishment in 2001, MindaNews has been living up to its vision of being the “leading provider of accurate, timely and comprehensive news and information on Mindanao and its peoples, serving economically, politically and culturally empowered communities” and its mission to “professionally and responsibly cover Mindanao events, peoples and issues to inform, educate, inspire and influence communities.”

MindaNews was founded by reporters precisely to ensure that reports about Mindanao, an island grouping that has suffered misinformation and disinformation long before these words became fashionable, are accurate. 

Our policy has always been to ensure that reports are thoroughly vetted before they are dispatched and uploaded on our website. 

Our fact-checking initiative with a uniform format started in October 2021 as part of Internews’ pioneering Philippine Fact-Checker Incubator (PFCI) project. Internews is an international non-profit that supports independent media from 100 countries. 

Prior to the PFCI project, MindaNews co-founded Tsek.ph, a collaboration among Philippine media institutions to fight disinformation and misinformation during the 2019. Tsek.ph did the same thing for the 2022 elections. 

Where do you get funds?

MindaNews has sustained its operation through proceeds from subscriptions of its news service  (news, special reports, opinion pieces, photos) and sales of books. It also receives grants from non-state actors.  Editorial prerogative, however, is left entirely to MindaNews. 

MindaNews does not accept funds from politicians or domestic or foreign states for its fact-checking initiative. For the other operations of MindaNews as a media organization in the past two years, we have received grants from the National Endowment for Democracy and the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization, which we use for coverage, staff compensation, administrative expenses and to train other journalists.

MindaNews Fact Check is supported by a grant from Internews.

Do you accept leads from the public for your fact-checking initiative?

MindaNews encourages the public to provide us with leads not only for potential fact-check pieces but other news stories as well of interest to the general public.

Our fact checks include this paragraph encouraging readers to be part of the process: “As with all our other reports, MindaNews welcomes leads or suggestions from the public to potential fact check pieces.”

MindaNews Fact Check - Methodology

What standards do you follow when fact-checking?

As a news organization, we strictly adhere to accuracy, fairness, balance, independence, accountability and transparency not just in our fact-checking initiative but in all other aspects of our work at MindaNews.

We abide by the Philippine Press Institute’s Journalist’s Code of Ethics. Since we became part of Internews’ Philippine Fact-Checker Incubator project, we have been striving to adhere with the IFCN Code of Principles, in step with our organization’s commitment to non-partisanship, transparency and fairness.

We fact-check a claim that is specifically claimed to be a fact and involved the public interest or the welfare of the people. We debunk false claims using official government records, journals or interviews with experts. 

We don’t fact-check opinions.

How do we fact-check?

Step 1: Team members monitor press conferences, speeches, statements, news, interviews, social media sites, etc. for statements worth fact-checking.

Step 2: When a claim is worth fact-checking, a team member looks for multiple sources to dispute the claim, including tracing the original source document.

Step 3:  Fact-checked claims are then submitted to the editor for copy editing and vetting. The link/s to debunk the claim are always included in the story.  

Step 4: A rating card is prepared to accompany the fact-checked piece, or infographics if needed, to immediately flag readers what the article is all about. 

Step 5: The senior editor takes another look before the article is posted on the website and social media accounts.

Correction Policy

Consistent with our vision and mission as a media institution, we rectify any error committed. If you spot a factual error, you may notify us thru editor@mindanews.com or our Facebook Messenger @Mindanews.

Correction Workflow

  • Errors pointed out are immediately brought to the attention of the editors and the fact-checking team. 

  • The fact-checker is immediately notified for verification. 

  • Once verified, the error is to be corrected within 24 hours and vetted before publication on the website. 

  • Readers will immediately know errors have been corrected through the Editor’s note posted above the article. 

  • The person who notified MindaNews about the error will be informed that the correction has been made.

About MindaNews

MindaNews is the news service arm of the Mindanao Institute of Journalism (MinJourn). It is composed of independent, professional journalists who believe and practice people empowerment through media. MinJourn, which is duly registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission with registration number CN201700385, is managed by its Board of Directors. 

MindaNews values its journalistic independence. It started in May 2001 as a media cooperative and in January 2017 registered as a nonstock, nonprofit media organization.  We do not  accept funding from politicians, political parties or partisan groups.

Editorial staff

Editor-in-Chief: Carolyn O. Arguillas
Editors: Robert D. Timonera, Bong S. Sarmiento, H. Marcos C. Mordeno
Reporters/Photojournalists: Froilan Gallardo, Antonio L. Colina IV, Ferdinandh B. Cabrera, Roel Catoto, Manman Dejeto, Allen Estabillo, Frencie Carreon, Richel V. Umel, Chris Panganiban
Social Media Manager: Yas D. Ocampo

Fact-checking Unit: Romer (Bong) Sarmiento, Yas D. Ocampo

Mindanao Institute of Journalism Board of Directors

President: Rhodora Gail T. Ilagan, PhD
Vice President: Romer (Bong) Sarmiento

Carolyn O. Arguillas
Jose Jowel Canuday, PhD
Robert D. Timonera

Chief Executive Officer: Jose Jowel Canuday, PhD
Board Secretary: Ellen Alinea
Board Treasurer: Amalia B. Cabusao